The Yelp Conundrum: Responding to Negative, False Online Reviews

Peter Chapman (in white) is general manager of Alaska Auto Rental in Fairbanks.
Peter Chapman (in white) is general manager of Alaska Auto Rental in Fairbanks.

Negative online reviews on websites like Yelp can affect a company’s overall rating by its customers. But how can you best handle a negative review of events that aren’t even true?

This is what happened to Peter Chapman, owner of Alaska Auto Rental. A supposed customer left a one-star review on Alaska Auto Rental’s Yelp page. The reviewer claimed that the counter agent overcharged her and wouldn’t let her keep the car an extra day. She also claimed that a tow truck took the vehicle and kicked her and her child onto the side of the road.

Chapman read the review and responded on the page in a professional manner. Through his response, he was able to clarify that she didn’t rent a vehicle from his company. In fact, the vehicle she was driving was rented by someone else and she didn’t have authorization to drive it. Additionally, the person who rented the vehicle had stopped paying for it and refused to return it as required by his rental agreement.

“After reviewing our call log, I found that the staff member who assisted you was courteous and respectful in his responses to you,” Chapman wrote in his response. “During your conversation, you became agitated and hung up on him. Our goal is to be polite and respectful to every customer. While you may not have appreciated the fact that we did not allow you to continue driving a vehicle that you did not rent or pay for, our staff informed you of the circumstances in a polite and respectful way. After you and the legitimate renter refused to return it, we located the unoccupied vehicle and recovered it.”

In his response, Chapman explained what really happened in this situation and was able to emphasize that his company still treated her with respect — even when she wasn’t a legitimate renter.

A screenshot of the negative Yelp review
A screenshot of the negative Yelp review

The problem with Yelp, says Chapman and others, is that there is no system yet to remove demonstrably false statements. Those reviews can be disputed in writing to inform readers, yet the one star is still counted toward the average.

Yelp’s policy regarding false or defamatory reviews is found in its online Support Center: “If you see a questionable review, please report it and include any information that our moderators can independently verify. Please note, however, that we don't typically take sides in factual disputes and generally allow Yelpers to stand behind their reviews.”

One countermeasure, at least, is to maintain quality service to drive positive reviews, to dilute the impact of negative ones. After this negative review, the same rental agent received a positive Yelp review a few days later. The customer described the rental agent as being “super helpful” and “lovely to chat with.”

A screenshot of the positive Yelp review
A screenshot of the positive Yelp review


  1. Mike [ February 14, 2017 @ 03:09AM ]

    Yelps system is flawed and allows business owners to be tarnished by patrons that only share their version of the story. This is particularly damaging to small businesses and Yelp stands behind their system because they feel they know it all. Their site has become where people go to complain rather than to praise & allows skews the image of a good business because of a faulty system. Yelp is more damaging than good and should have a YELP section for their own site....see what people have to say about them

Comment On This Story

Comment: (Max. 10000 characters)  
Please leave blank:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.


Newsletter: Sign up to receive latest news, articles, and much more.

Read the latest

Auto Focus Blog: A blog covering fleets, auto rental and the business of cars

Trends Moving the Truck Market

Storylines that emerged from the 2018 Work Truck Show include the increasing need for on-site productivity, inclusion of active safety systems in trucks, DPF frustrations affecting product decisions, data management, and the growing link between fleet management and company revenue.

MIT Study Reinforces the Newfound Importance of Fleet

Uber and Lyft drivers make far less when factoring vehicle expenses, though the actual numbers are now in dispute. A proper lifecycle cost analysis would’ve helped, and shows the benefit of collaboration with fleet professionals.

What a Connected Fleet Means to Avis (and Car Rental)

Counter bypass is just the beginning. The promise of a “data-driven ecosystem” that connects renters with the rental agency, retail services, and even the city is a better managed fleet, an improved user experience, and new revenue opportunities during the rental itself.

Job Finder: Access Top Talent. Fill Key Positions.