Budget Loses Vicarious Liability Case in N.Y.

NEW YORK -- The New York State Supreme Court has ruled against Budget Rent A Car and upheld a $20.3 million award in a vicarious liability case arising from a Nov. 29, 2000, accident in lower Manhattan that left a man paralyzed.

The judgment follows a year of post-trial challenges by Budget to overturn or reduce the $24.5 million that a jury awarded the plaintiff, Ethan Ruby, in Dec. 2003. The Supreme Court reduced the judgment from $24.5 million to $20.3 million, ruling that Ruby's attorneys failed to establish a need for some of the tests and medical treatments that they factored into Ruby's future healthcare expenses.

According to court testimony, the accident occurred after the driver of a Budget rental car ran a red light and collided with a van that careened into the crosswalk at Delancy and Orchard streets, where Ruby was legally crossing the street on foot.

New York state law stipulates that car rental companies, as owners of their vehicles, are liable for their customers' negligence in accidents involving injury or death to a third party. The $20.3 million award takes into account Ruby's loss of earnings, medical costs, and pain and suffering. At the time of the accident, Ruby was 25.

Comment On This Story

Name:  
Email:  
Comment: (Max. 10000 characters)  
Please leave blank:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.

 
 

Newsletter: Sign up to receive latest news, articles, and much more.

Read the latest

Auto Focus Blog: A blog covering fleets, auto rental and the business of cars

Understanding The Fleetification of Everything

As fleet miles increase exponentially, and as new stratum of fleet enter both consumer and business use cases, the "founding fathers" who gathered at Fleet Forward in Miami last week have some work to do.

The Problem with Valuing Safety Technology

As advanced safety technologies have migrated to mainstream vehicles, retaining value for these options at resale remains an issue.

ELD Mandate: Is Your Head Still in the Sand?

If you think you have 11 weeks to implement an Electronic Logging Device system to meet the Dec. 18 compliance deadline, you really don’t — for a few reasons.

Job Finder: Access Top Talent. Fill Key Positions.

>