Gap Shrinking Between New and Used Prices

The gap between new- and used-vehicle pricing in many segments has narrowed significantly, with new vehicles, on average, selling for only 11.5% more than a comparable 1-year-old used car, reports Alec Gutierrez, senior market analyst of automotive insights, Kelley Blue Book. 

Used subcompact and compact cars only offer consumers an average savings between 5 to 7%, while used hybrid cars and mid-size crossovers are within 3 to 4% of an equivalent new vehicle.  After factoring in incentives and lower finance APRs on new cars, purchasing a new vehicle is in many cases only marginally more than purchasing used. 

While traditionally shoppers would save thousands of dollars by purchasing a slightly used vehicle rather than new, this is no longer the case. As used-car values remain near their all-time peak, Kelley Blue Book sees new-vehicle sales cannibalizing used vehicle sales. 

During the past several months, Kelley Blue Book has observed a shift in shopper activity from used to new vehicles based on the 14 million visitors to KBB.com each month, as well as new- and used-vehicle sales.  In terms of Web traffic on the company’s car-shopping website, there has been a 5 percentage point shift in new-car shopper activity since January.  Similarly, new-vehicle sales have been increasing consistently year-over-year (increasing 9% in July alone), while used-vehicle registrations declined by 4 to 5% year-over-year from March through May.

The choice to purchase a new or used car can certainly vary depending on the model being considered.  For instance, a consumer considering a Ford Focus can save as much as $3,000 by purchasing a used model-year 2011; however, the strength of the 2012 redesign may prompt them to spend a little more on the latest and greatest model.  A consumer in the market for a Toyota FJ Cruiser should almost always opt to buy new.  A brand new 2012 FJ Cruiser currently has a Fair Purchase Price of $28,500, a mere $300 more than a used 2011 FJ Cruiser with 20,000 miles.

To assist consumers in identifying those vehicles that may make more sense to buy new, Kelley Blue Book has compiled a list of 10 new vehicles that are only marginally more expensive than their 1-year-old counterpart.


10 New Vehicles to Buy New Rather Than Used
Make Model Trim New MSRP Kelley Blue Book Fair Purchase Price (NEW)* Kelley Blue Book Sugg. Retail Value (USED)

New - Used

$/%

Chevrolet Camaro LT Coupe 2D $26,180 $25,261 $25,135 $126/0.5%
Toyota 4Runner SR5 Sport Utility 4D $33,640 $32,294 $32,040 $254/0.8%
Toyota FJ Cruiser Sport Utility 2D $28,515 $28,444 $28,200 $244/0.9%
Subaru Impreza 2.0i Sedan 4D $18,245 $17,450 $17,300 $150/0.9%
Jeep Wrangler Sport SUV 2D $22,970 $22,281 $22,000 $281/1.3%
Honda Fit Sport Hatchback 4D $17,850 $17,234 $17,000 $234/1.4%
Volkswagen Golf TDI Hatchback 4D $25,705 $24,168 $23,730 $438/1.8%
Kia Rio LX Sedan 4D $14,150 $13,433 $13,150 $283/2.1%
Mazda MAZDA2 SPort Hatchback 4D $15,325 $14,406 $14,100 $306/2.2%
Chevrolet Equinox LT Sport Utility 4D $25,875 $24,845 $24,305 $540/2.2%


*Fair Purchase Price reflects value of a MY2012 new vehicle while Sugg. Retail Value reflects a MY2011 used vehicle.

Comment On This Story

Name:  
Email:  
Comment: (Max. 10000 characters)  
Please leave blank:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.

Newsletter: Sign up to receive latest news, articles, and much more.

Read the latest

Auto Focus Blog: A blog covering fleets, auto rental and the business of cars

Autonomous Vehicles and the Changing Role of the Fleet Manager

With fewer drivers and substantially longer fleet lifecycles, fleet managers will pivot to new job functions.

2017: Fleet Mix Will Be Paramount

Car rental companies are migrating to vehicle segments with better residual values, though not without bumps in the road.

Auto Rental Summit: Five Trend Lines

Taking in the seminars, discussions, and networking at the 2016 Auto Rental Summit, trend lines emerged around shifts in model mix, data protection issues, increasing labor costs, workforce engagement, and new platforms to rent cars.

Job Finder: Access Top Talent. Fill Key Positions.