Calif. Court Rules on Excess Insurance Liability in Rental Car Case
Rental company must check drivers' licenses, insurance company does not have to pay claims if license later determined to be fraudulent.
The California Supreme Court said Dec. 7 that insurance companies that offer so-called excess liability insurance on rental cars don't have to pay if an apparently valid driver's license later turns out to be fraudulent, according to the Bay City News Wire.
The court ruled in a case in which four people who were injured in a 2001 auto accident in Los Angeles sought compensation from a $1 million excess liability policy issued by the Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. to a rental car driver.
The driver, Alric Burke of Arizona, bought the policy when he rented a car from Budget Rent-A-Car at Los Angeles International Airport in June 2001. He was involved in the accident four days later, the Bay City News Wire reports.
The optional policy was intended to cover any damages that might exceed the state-law-required minimum insurance of $30,000 per accident.
A Budget agent checked Burke's license, which appeared to be valid, and also verified his signature when he rented the car. But it later turned out that Burke's license had been suspended in Arizona two months earlier.
Philadelphia Indemnity refused to pay the claims, saying that it was entitled to rescind the insurance contract because of Burke's misrepresentation.
The state high court said unanimously that Philadelphia Indemnity was sheltered by a state law that defines rental car companies' responsibility to check driver's licenses. The law, enacted by the Legislature in 1994, requires rental companies to inspect a car renter's license and compare the signature on the license with the renter's signature in the presence of an agent.
Because the Budget agent met those requirements, the insurance company was not required to make an additional investigation, the court said.
More Rental Operations

Turo to Launch Vehicle Delivery Service
Turo Delivered will let travelers search for vehicles that hosts can deliver directly to hotels, homes, airports, train stations, and other locations.
Read More →
Palm Beach Airport Code Change Creates Car Rental Distribution Gap
A test of rental searches under the old PBI and new DJT airport codes returned largely different sets of brands and vehicles, highlighting a potential distribution problem for rental operators.
Read More →
U-Save Continues Dominican Republic Expansion with Launch in Punta Cana
The new franchise location builds on U-Save’s existing Santo Domingo operation and will begin taking reservations for October 2026.
Read More →
When AI Books the Rental Car, Who Controls the Sale?
As AI moves from comparing rental rates to completing transactions, operators need to understand how travelers find, interpret, rank, and ultimately see their offers. (Part 2 of 2.)
Read More →
European Booked Car Rental Rates Fell 5%, Results Varied by Country
Ireland, Cyprus, and the United Kingdom saw steep declines, while booked rates rose in Poland and Hungary.
Read More →Is It Time to Rethink Rental Categories?
As traditional economy and compact cars disappear from the market, longtime rental operator Mike DeLorenzo asks whether the industry’s familiar vehicle categories still make sense — and what operators need to rethink along with them.
Read More →
Who Owns the Rate? AI Is Creating a New Distribution Problem for Car Rental
Generative Engine Optimization asks whether AI can find a rental company, but operators also need to know whether the agent inspected enough of the market, compared equivalent offers, and presented a rate the traveler can actually book. (Part 1 of 2)
Read More →
U.S. Business Travel Car Rental Rates Forecast to Rise Up to 2%
Improved fleet supply should limit pricing gains in 2026-27, while insurance, repair costs, and softer residual values continue to pressure rental operations, according to Amex GBT.
Read More →
Sixt Revenue Tops $2.4 Billion in First Half of 2026
Sixt’s first-half revenue surpassed $2.4 billion for the first time as demand outpaced fleet growth, lifting utilization and earnings despite weaker consumer sentiment in North America.
Read More →
In Memoriam: Bobby Klyce, Avis Licensee Legend
The longtime Birmingham Avis operator and 2018 Auto Rental News Impact Award recipient was remembered as an advocate for independent licensees and the broader car rental industry.
Read More →
