Auto Rental News
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Car Rental Q&A: How Can Independents Compete With the Majors?

An independent car rental operator asks for tips on how to compete with the major car rental companies.

by Sharon Faulkner
September 8, 2015
4 min to read


Q: I'm an independent car rental company and it's always a struggle to compete with the majors. Do you have any strategies?

— Elia Sikanen, Ambassador Rent A Car, Lake Worth, Fla.

Ad Loading...

A: As an independent car rental company, it is difficult to compete with the majors. The majors will always have more buying power and a bigger presence, but here are 14 tips to help build your presence in your local market:

1. Create a recognizable brand name. Consider a franchise or an affiliate program so you can afford to be on as many search engines as possible. Renters may feel uncomfortable renting from a company they have never heard of.

2. Increase your online presence. As a small independent, it’s not feasible to be listed on the major travel search engines such as Expedia and Orbitz. However, look into portals like Car Rental Express (carrentalexpress.com) that cater to smaller companies.

Also, understanding SEO (search engine optimization) best practices in your local market can help your company gain a listing on the front page of search engines like Google and Yahoo.

3. Don’t underprice your product too far below your competition. Hold fast to higher prices until bookings pick up — or until the majors’ reservations are growing and they move up their pricing, too.

Ad Loading...

4. Never underestimate the power of excellent customer service. Renters may initially choose you because you had the best price, but they will choose you the next time because they were treated so royally.

If you have renters that you want to impress, make sure they remember you. Give them a bottle of water for their trip or a small snack bag with something representing your location, such as an apple for New York or cheese from Wisconsin. A small gesture can turn a one-time client into a longtime one.

5. Know what your competition is renting and offering. Instead of complaining about the competition, emulate them. Do they have separate lines for repeat renters or members-only clients? If so, you should consider doing the same.

6. Understand the value of uniformed employees with name badges. This professional touch helps instill confidence in the renter that this is a well-run rental agency.

7. Keep a clean and orderly counter at all times. Being clean and organized helps your business look more professional. Your shuttle bus is also a reflection of your business so it’s important to keep it clean.

8. Encourage your employees to be take-charge people. Allow them to settle disputes under $50 and don’t question them after decisions have been made.

Ad Loading...

9. Work at the counter occasionally. If you as the owner/operator do not usually rent the cars, make a point to do it as often as you can to see if your quality and your personality are capable of bringing return business. Your employees will appreciate your participation, and your customers will feel important since the owner took time to meet and greet them.

10. Find replacement vehicles with your competition. If you run out of cars (and you should run out at least two days a week if your utilization is high enough to produce a profit), make sure you find a replacement vehicle with your competition.

If there is a price differential, send the renter a check with your company logo and contact information. That way, renters have visible proof of your commitment to their return business.

11. A niche market can be profitable. Passenger vans, handicap vans, luxury cars, camping vans or recreational vehicles (with camping rental equipment) can be in demand in certain niche markets, but you can still compete with a varied fleet.

12. Cultivate local small businesses. Small businesses like to use local car rental companies for statewide business trips. If they need the vehicles delivered and picked up, ensure that your company can accommodate that need.

Ad Loading...

13. Attend industry meetings. By interacting with your competitors, the more you can learn about what they do and how you can compete better.

14. Don’t underestimate your worth. As a smaller company, you can still compete and secure a market share that is desirable and profitable. And if you grow big enough, a major might deem you worth buying.

What's Your Question?

Email your car rental operation-related questions to Auto Rental News care of chris.brown@bobit.com.

Sharon Faulkner is the executive director for the American Car Rental Association (ACRA), the voice for the U.S. auto rental industry. The association supports and promotes sensible legislation that will benefit all of its car rental members. Faulkner can be reached at Sfaulkner@acraorg.com.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Rental Operations

Paperwork sits in front of a black Lamborghini
Rental Operations•November 1, 2026

Clean on Paper: Red Flags in Exotic Car Rental Verification

A suspicious $45,000 Lamborghini booking reveals the strengths and limitations of renter verification, from forged insurance documents to coverage gaps and unauthorized drivers. (Part 2 of 3)

Read More →
display of Turo's FSD homepage
Rental Operations•by Chris Brown•October 28, 2026

Turo and Tesla Take the Next Step Toward Autonomous Car Rentals

The partnership brings Tesla's Full Self-Driving (Supervised) technology into the rental experience, offering a glimpse of how increasingly automated vehicles could change car rental.

Read More →
Two identical rental cars, two different prices
Rental Operations•Cover Story•October 26, 2026

How Rental Operators Can Navigate Personalized Pricing Rules

As regulators scrutinize the use of customer data in pricing, rental operators need to know whether they can explain why one renter pays more than another.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
a laptop shows different connectivity paths for car rental supply
Rental Operations•October 23, 2026

Direct, Broker or Hybrid? How Travel Retailers Source Rental Cars

As travel retailers weigh direct supplier relationships against third-party distribution, rental operators need to understand how those decisions affect their business.

Read More →
thumbnail of title and photo of Joel Price and Chris Brown
Rental Operations•by Chris Brown•October 20, 2026

How Did This Independent Rental Operator Grow to 170 Vehicles in 4 Years?

With 170 vehicles across three Kentucky locations, Joel Price relies on an overseas team to handle reservations, payments, and after-hours customer service. It's one part of an unconventional approach to growing an independent rental operation.

Read More →
thumbnail what does it take to succeed in b2b rentals
Rental Operations•by Chris Brown•October 12, 2026

What Does It Take to Succeed in B2B Rentals?

The fundamentals may be familiar to daily car rental operators, but project-based truck rentals put different demands on the fleet and the business.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of Ana Laborde and world map
Rental Operations•by Chris Brown•October 12, 2026

NPR Builds on International Partnerships to Grow Rental Bookings

With Ana Laborde supporting broker development, NPR Auto Group is tailoring distribution strategies, rate packages, and partnerships to grow international reservations across its three brands.

Read More →
Rental car agent shows woman her choice of rental car
Rental Operations•by Chris Brown•October 7, 2026

Advantage, Sixt Place Among Top Five in Annual Satisfaction Study

While Enterprise and National retain the top spots in JD Power’s 2026 rankings, the latest customer satisfaction results suggest renters can find competitive service beyond the biggest car rental names.

Read More →
an exotic car wrapped in an insurance policy
Rental Operations•October 1, 2026

The $100,000 Insurance Trap in Exotic Car Rentals

Exotic rental agencies often rely on customers’ personal auto policies to protect six-figure vehicles. But policy language can dramatically change the coverage for vehicles over $100,000 MSRP.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
globe of world and drivers license from UK
Rental Operations•September 28, 2026

The Booking Is Confirmed, But Is Your Customer Ready to Drive?

For international renters, a confirmed reservation doesn’t always mean they’re eligible to drive. Earlier checks can help operators catch documentation and payment issues before the customer reaches the counter.

Read More →
Ad Loading...