Auto Rental News
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Resolving a 'Mexican Insurance Scam'

Renter booking a car for a Cancun trip ends up paying more than triple the rental cost in insurance.

by Staff
February 16, 2011
2 min to read


A reader question in a Seattle Times column has brought attention to what columnist Christopher Elliott described as "the old Mexican insurance scam," in which the renter was required to pay insurance, more than doubling the cost of the rental.

Elliott wrote that reader Gordon Houston of Calgary booked a car rental through Hotwire for $9.80 a day for a nine-day Cancun trip, expecting the total cost with taxes to be $97.

Ad Loading...

But when the renter arrived in Cancun, the Europcar agent said the renter must buy extra insurance. The renter was charged $268.

Elliott wrote that Hotwire should have disclosed the mandatory insurance, at least sometime before the renter signed the rental agreement. Hotwire's fine print, he added, appears to do an inadequate job of warning customers of the Mexico insurance rules.

Although the lack of clear disclosure only helps the car rental company, which profits from selling insurance. Hotwire bears some responsibility for failing to quote the renter a total price, Elliott wrote. 

Renters running into the same problem should write to Hotwire through Hotwire's website and also write to a company executive. Additionally, renters should send the letter to the insurance commissioner in their state and to the nearest American consulate in Mexico.  As a last resort, renters can dispute the credit card charges or sue Hotwire in small claims court.

How did the reader's situation get resolved? Columnist Elliott contacted Hotwire and said the company agreed to credit the renter for the extra money he was forced to spend on insurance.

More Rental Operations

green and blue bar graphs compare fleet sales June 2025 versus June 2026
Fleet Acquisitionby Martin RomjueJuly 8, 2026

Rental Car Fleet Sales Show Mid-Year Strength

June gains ensured rental fleets closed out the first half of 2026 in positive territory.

Read More →
Close up of a row of white CUVs in the Surprice Mobility fleet at the Milan airport.

Surprice Mobility Opens Corporate Rental Station at Milan Malpensa Airport

The Milan opening is part of Surprice Mobility's broader strategy to expand its corporate operations while increasing the use of technology across its network.

Read More →
Julian Gritsch with an MBA class in a classroom.

Brazilian Executive MBA Targets Growing Domestic Rental Car Industry

Rental car companies face a unique combination of challenges that are rarely addressed in traditional programs.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Green Motion team with banner bearing Japanese flag.

Green Motion Expands Into Japan With Master Franchise Agreement

Japan's tourism industry, business travel market, and demand for vehicle rental services are reasons the country represents an important market for the company.

Read More →
ACRA Chairman Sharky Laguana on stage at the ICRS event in Grapevine, Texas.
Legal & Legislativeby Martin RomjueJune 24, 2026

ACRA Carrying Fuller Industry Load As AI and EVs Lurk In Future

The leading car rental professional business group details an active legislative, regulatory, and macro-trends agenda affecting car rental operators.

Read More →
Light blue horizontal bar graphs on a chart showing World Cup-related rental car booking trends.
Rental OperationsJune 23, 2026

World Cup Travel Data Shows Longer Car Rentals and More One-Ways

A recent analysis of FIFA bookings found varied demand patterns that influenced rental car pricing.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Side view of ICRS speaker Sanchit Garg at podium in front of a floor lit red curtain
Rental Operationsby Martin RomjueJune 22, 2026

A Leveling Force: AI Morphs Into A Rental Car Profit-Seeker

Revenue managers can’t match the emerging AI tools gobbling lots of data that could counter the competitive race to the rate bottom.

Read More →
Photos of Martin Romjue and Denis Gjoni on opposite sides of large headline for the video.
Rental Operationsby Martin RomjueJune 17, 2026

Stop Losing Money On Rental Tolls

Regardless of your rental fleet size and structure, fleet managers, executives, and owners can gain valuable insights into an often-overlooked area of fleet operations.

Read More →
Richard Lowden gesturing on stage in front of a red curtain at the Gaylord Texan Resort near Dallas.
Rental Operationsby Martin RomjueJune 12, 2026

Rethink The Future To Avert A Race To The Bottom

Rental car operators heard a sobering industry message and a stern challenge at the close of the International Car Rental Show.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
John Possumato holding microphone while asking a question during a live conference session at the ICRS Show.

DriveItAway, Free2move Plan Shared Fleet Program for Independent Rental Fleet Operators

Vehicles would be placed with participating rental operations to support car renter demand and provide additional fleet capacity.

Read More →
Ad Loading...