Auto Rental News
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Some New Cars Now Less Expensive Than Used Cars, Edmunds.com Reports

With the limited supply of used vehicles, shoppers can save as much as $8,460 by purchasing a new car instead of a used version of the same vehicle.

by Staff
December 23, 2009
2 min to read


Edmunds.com said that the deals on some new cars are so generous that they actually make the new car less expensive than the one-year-old used version of the same model.

Some of the cars on the list are:

Ad Loading...

•2009 Audi Q7
•2009 Buick Enclave
•2009 Mazda B-Series Truck
•2009 Volvo C30 T5
•2009 Toyota Highlander Hybrid

The full list of cars and trucks is available at http://www.edmunds.com/industry-car-news/new-vs-used-car-buying.html.

To perform this analysis, Edmunds.com compared the vehicles' True Market Value transaction prices and the interest payments typically made for each vehicle.* Edmunds.com’s analysts determined that this month, a shopper can save as much as $8,460 by purchasing the new car instead of the used car.

Why is this strange phenomenon happening?

“Demand and supply dynamics are causing an increase in used car prices while lowering new car prices across the board, generally speaking,” observed Edmunds.com Analyst Joe Spina. “Used cars are in limited supply for three main reasons: first, there are fewer vehicles coming off lease this year because of the recent decline in leasing’s popularity and availability. Second, ‘Cash for Clunkers’ rendered many thousands of used vehicles inoperable and removed them from the scene at an unnaturally high rate. Third, because of the economy people are holding onto their cars longer. Much of the used car supply typically comes from trade-ins for new car purchases, but that is simply not happening at the same level as in past years. Used car sales are only down about three percent despite the shortage in supply, while new car sales are down nearly 25 percent compared with last year.”

Ad Loading...

*Edmunds.com assumed a 60-month loan term with a 5.3% "typical" finance rate for new cars and 8.5% finance rate for used cars. Edmunds.com included destination charges and gas guzzler taxes as appropriate. Of all available rebates, only national APR subvention and dealer cash programs were applied; consumers should check the Edmunds.com Incentives and Rebates database to learn if they qualify for additional savings.

More Fleet Acquisition

A green and black bar graph chart comparing April 2025 v. 2026 sales into commercial, rental, and government fleets.
Fleet Acquisitionby Martin RomjueMay 5, 2026

Monthly Rental Fleet Sales Dip Again As YTD Numbers Flatten

Pull-ahead demand for rental cars in the second half of 2025 appears to be slowing purchases so far this year.

Read More →
Map of the U.S. highlighting participating DriveItAway dealerships behind three fleet vehicles.

DriveItAway Transitions To OTCID, Expands To 40 U.S. Markets

The dual milestone propels the company toward its goals of accessing longer-term capital markets and deploying a national platform.

Read More →
Green and black bar graphs show YOY fleet sales comparisons among rental, commercial, and government sectors.
Fleet Acquisitionby Martin RomjueApril 3, 2026

Rental Fleet Sales Stay Ahead In Q1 Despite Monthly Dip

Vehicle sales into commercial fleets are outpacing rental car fleet purchases so far this year.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Green and black bar graphs showing YOY shifts in February fleet sales.
Fleet Acquisitionby Martin RomjueMarch 5, 2026

Rental Fleet Sales Slow In February Ending A Strong Streak

Commercial fleets posted the most gains, sustaining increases in monthly and year-to-date fleet sales

Read More →
Intro page to video featuring Bill Wallschlaeger and Martin Romjue
Rental Operationsby Martin RomjueMarch 3, 2026

How It's Still Possible To Run An Electric Rental Fleet

This Season 2 / Episode 4 of Auto Rental News’ Industry Newsmakers series broaches a difficult subject in car rental: How do you make EVs succeed?

Read More →
Rental cars lined up in front of an Avis-Budget storefront outlet.
Rental Operationsby News/Media ReleaseFebruary 20, 2026

Avis Budget Group Reports Near $1 Billion Loss Tied To 2025 EV Fleet Write-Down

Following Hertz, the company is the second global car rental conglomerate to sustain sizable losses due to lower customer demand and usage of electric rental cars.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Green and black bar graphs show the rise in fleet sales from January 2025 to January 2026.
Fleet Acquisitionby Martin RomjueFebruary 4, 2026

Rental Fleet Sales Shoot Ahead From The Starting Line

Rental car operations continued their 2025 reputation as the top driver of fleet sales.

Read More →
8-photo collage of city skylines where DriveItAway is expanding.
Rental Softwareby News/Media ReleaseJanuary 30, 2026

DriveItAway, Free2move Expand To Eight More U.S. Cities

As of the end of January, the platform now operates its flexible lease and vehicle subscription services in 21 major U.S. markets.

Read More →
An orange and purple bar graph shows average rental car prices and mileage levels from October 2024 to October 2025.
RemarketingJanuary 16, 2026

2025 Rental Vehicle Remarketing Summary And Outlook

The year brought modest and flatter results across wholesale values, total off-rental supply, and rental risk units.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
AuctionNet summary table of Dec. 25 auction vehicle sales with three columns.
Fleet Acquisitionby News/Media ReleaseJanuary 13, 2026

Auctions Record Highest Vehicle Sales Since 2019

2025 figures show a steady recovery in wholesale vehicle activity this decade.

Read More →
Ad Loading...