Lawsuit Over Avis Refueling Charge Dismissed
Judge says rental contract made clear that the fee was avoidable; plaintiff says charging $3.85 per gallon above the market rate is "pure profit" for Avis.
Avis Budget Group Inc. won dismissal of a lawsuit by a customer claiming its $5.99-a-gallon refueling charge is illegal, Bloomberg News reports.
The customer, Andrew Ramon, said Avis Budget Rent a Car System Inc. imposed an "unreasonably large" service charge to refuel cars returned with less than full tanks. Ramon didn't elect to prepay for a full tank of gas at a market rate of $2.14 a gallon.
Ramon "not only rejected the prepaid fuel option but agreed to the terms of the refueling service charge, an avoidable fee of $5.99 per gallon which was clearly identified and explained in the agreement," Martini ruled. "Ultimately, plaintiff was charged the precise amount he agreed to under the contract. The court fails to see how this could possibly amount to a breach."
Ramon, of San Antonio, spent $11.42 for the fuel after returning the car with the tank less than full. He sought class-action status for his suit, saying the $3.85 a gallon above the market rate was "pure profit."
Martini rejected Ramon's arguments on several legal grounds, including that the charge violated New Jersey consumer fraud law, according to Bloomberg News.
The complaint "fails to identify or describe any misrepresentations made by Budget with respect to the refueling service charge," Martini wrote in a 13-page opinion.
More Rental Operations
U.S. Business Travel Car Rental Rates Forecast to Rise Up to 2%
Improved fleet supply should limit pricing gains in 2026-27, while insurance, repair costs, and softer residual values continue to pressure rental operations, according to Amex GBT.
Read More →
Sixt Revenue Tops $2.4 Billion in First Half of 2026
Sixt’s first-half revenue surpassed $2.4 billion for the first time as demand outpaced fleet growth, lifting utilization and earnings despite weaker consumer sentiment in North America.
Read More →
In Memoriam: Bobby Klyce, Avis Licensee Legend
The longtime Birmingham Avis operator and 2018 Auto Rental News Impact Award recipient was remembered as an advocate for independent licensees and the broader car rental industry.
Read More →
How to Build Custom Fleet Tools With AI and Vibe Coding [Webinar]
A new Automotive Fleet webinar explores how fleet managers are using AI and vibe coding to automate routine work and create simple operational tools without traditional programming skills.
Read More →
Car Rental Rates Forecast to Rise 3.6% in 2026 Before Easing in 2027
Car rental rates are projected to rise less than airfares and hotel rates in 2026, then become the only major travel category forecast to decline in 2027, according to projections from GBTA and ALTOUR.
Read More →
Avis Cuts Fleet as Summer Demand Trails Expectations
Avis Budget Group increased second-quarter earnings despite lower Americas revenue and softer-than-expected summer demand. The company also expanded Avis First and advanced its autonomous fleet operations with Waymo.
Read More →
Why Bookings Are Only the Start of the Rental Day
A reservation captures demand. The operating test is whether the business can keep the customer, vehicle, commercial terms, and next action aligned until the rental is closed.
Read More →
This Is the Oldest Car Rental Advertisement You’ll Ever See
This ad for Saunders Drive it Yourself, believed to be the first car rental company in the U.S., was found in an Omaha phone book from 1926.
Read More →
The Desk Upsell Is Costing Operators More Than it Earns
Counter upsells generate revenue, but they can also slow transactions, erode trust, and cost repeat business. Fully inclusive pricing may offer operators a better path to long-term value.
Read More →
U-Save Expands Indian Ocean Presence with New Master Franchise for Mauritius
The franchise has been acquired by Mauritian travel entrepreneur Umarfarooq Omarjee, an established figure in the island's tourism and mobility sector.
Read More →