Auto Rental News
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Tourist Sues Over Arizona Stadium Tax

PHOENIX --– A Michigan man is suing Maricopa County, Ariz., because he had to pay increased taxes on his hotel room and car rental while visiting two years ago.

by Staff
July 27, 2005
2 min to read


PHOENIX --– A Michigan man is suing Maricopa County, Ariz., because he had to pay increased taxes on his hotel room and car rental while visiting two years ago.

Those taxes imposed on tourists are collected by the Tourism and Sports Authority to pay for the new Arizona Cardinals football stadium in Glendale.

Ad Loading...

The disgruntled tourist, Michael Devine, claims that the taxes are illegal because they are aimed at out-of-state travelers.

According to Devine's attorney, Greg Hanley, the tax is unconstitutional. Hanley said that the federal constitution has the Dormant Commerce Clause, which prevents states from discriminating against interstate commerce – treating state residents better than the visitors. He says the best example of that is a tax that isn't imposed on the people that benefit from it.

"Our complaint's allegation is that this rental car tax and hotel tax target visitors and seek to shift the burden of building this new stadium from the Arizona taxpayers to the visitors who don’t have a voice in whether the tax should have been approved," Hanley says. He suggests that the only way the tax could have been pushed through politically was to sell it as a tax on tourists.

If Devine and Hanley have success, the ramifications could possibly see a reversal of similar taxes in other parts of the country, however, Hanley sees Arizona as unique.

"The Arizona case, in our view, was unique because the discrimination was so blatant and evident," he said.

Ad Loading...

The complaint was just recently filed, but the case has been progressing for about a year.

More Rental Operations

50 states map showing LOR rates for each state with different shades of light to dark green

U.S. Rental Length Declines Slightly in Q1 2026, Enterprise Reports

LOR overall continues to trend downward, but ongoing market and economic conditions could affect future results while the industry deals with staffing and productivity challenges.

Read More →
Illustration of a driverless futuristic front seat/dashboard view of other cars on a freeway with city skyline on horizon.

Hertz, Uber Deepen Roles In Self-Driving And Driver-Led Fleet Services

The business arrangement connects demand with scalable fleet management services and supports a range of mobility uses.

Read More →
A tech collage of electronic devices against a computer chip blueprint map.
Rental OperationsMay 1, 2026

Why Car Rental Can No Longer Run On Workarounds

The shift from branch-based software to connected operations is turning rental technology into strategic infrastructure.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A tech collage of electronic devices against a computer chip blueprint map.
Rental OperationsMay 1, 2026

Why Car Rental Can No Longer Run On Workarounds

The shift from branch-based software to connected operations is turning rental technology into strategic infrastructure.

Read More →
A black Audi SUV superimposed on a historic scene from downtown Tashkent, Uzbekistan.

Carwiz Sets Up Rental Operations In Central Asia

The global franchise operation reaches a first in its rental fleet portfolio with new service in Uzbekistan.

Read More →
A raging brushfire in the countryside.
Rental Operationsby Martin RomjueApril 30, 2026

Where Rental Fleets Must Adjust To Shifting Catastrophe Risks

West Coast disasters pose unique challenges and liabilities for rental fleet operators, who are advised to take steps tailored to their specific situations.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
ARN Industry Newsmakers thumbnail page with ARN and ICRS logos and shots of Nick DiPrima and Martin Romjue
Rental Operationsby Martin RomjueApril 27, 2026

Using AI To Find Rental Car Damage

Angry car renters are storming social media, the mainstream media, and online ratings platforms to complain about charges they claim are either unfounded or excessive.

Read More →
Photo of CEO Krešimir Dobrilović against a gray modernist crooked-tile mural display.

Carwiz Opens Car Rental Service In Panama

A Carwiz partner in Puerto Rico is taking on the Panama franchise with operations in the nation's largest airport.

Read More →
A world map with Flexways logo and new locations headline.

Flexways Opens 10 Locations Among Franchise, Affiliate Rental Networks

The integrated business model combines each operator’s local expertise with international standards to boost sales.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of a suitcase, passport, and smartphone.

Traveler Customer Satisfaction Up This Year Data Study Shows

The study looks at customer analytics to size up performance in car rentals, rideshare, airlines, lodging, and OTAs.

Read More →
Ad Loading...