Auto Rental News
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Which Is Cheaper, Ride-Hailing or Car Rental?

An Amex GBT comparison of airport trips in 10 U.S. cities found that rental was the clear winner for some one-day trips. But trip length, parking, fuel, and the number of local journeys can change the calculation.

Chris Brown
Chris BrownAssociate Publisher
Read Chris's Posts
August 30, 2026
ride hailing driver on left, car rental driver on right

The best comparison isn't daily rate versus single fares, but the total cost of an itinerary.

Credit:

Auto Rental News

4 min to read


Is it cheaper to rent a car or use ride-hailing after arriving at the airport? An analysis from American Express Global Business Travel found there is no universal answer.

Amex GBT compared the cost of an airport-to-city-center round trip in 10 major U.S. business travel markets. The analysis considered average daily rental rates, ride-hail fares, tolls and parking charges.

Ad Loading...

For a one-day trip, car rental was clearly less expensive than ride-hailing in five of the 10 cities studied: Chicago, Detroit, Los Angeles, Phoenix and San Francisco.

In four other markets — Atlanta, Dallas, Houston and New York — the listed rental price was lower than the ride-hail fare, but Amex GBT classified the comparison as borderline because adding fuel could eliminate the rental advantage.

Charlotte was the only market in which the listed one-day rental cost was already higher than the ride-hail round trip before accounting for fuel.

One-Day Rental Costs Varied by Market

The largest apparent one-day rental advantage occurred in San Francisco. Amex GBT calculated a $75.27 one-day rental cost for a trip between San Francisco International Airport and the Transamerica Pyramid, compared with $126.86 for ride-hailing.

In Los Angeles, the comparison was $93 for a one-day rental versus $124.90 for a ride-hail round trip between Los Angeles International Airport and the Museum of Contemporary Art.

Ad Loading...

Other comparisons in which rental had a clear advantage included:

  • Chicago: $67.49 for rental versus $92.89 for ride-hailing.
  • Detroit: $72 for rental versus $110.39 for ride-hailing.
  • Phoenix: $60.88 for rental versus $87.87 for ride-hailing.

The Dallas comparison was nearly even: $62.88 for a one-day rental versus $62.91 for ride-hailing. Any fuel expense would make ride-hailing the less expensive option in that scenario.

In Charlotte, ride-hailing cost $49.86 for the round trip, compared with $63.15 for a one-day rental.

Two-Day Trips Shifted the Advantage to Ride-Hailing

The result changed when the rental extended into a second day.

Ad Loading...

In the scenario modeled by Amex GBT, ride-hailing was less expensive in all 10 cities when the traveler kept the rental vehicle for two days but needed only an airport-to-city trip and the return journey.

The reason is straightforward: The ride-hail customer paid for two individual trips, while the renter accumulated a second day of rental charges along with potential parking and fuel expenses.


In New York, for example, the report estimated a $168.72 ride-hail round trip between LaGuardia Airport and the New York Stock Exchange. The estimated rental cost was $150 for one day and $286.50 for two days.

In San Francisco, the $75.27 one-day rental increased to $150.54 over two days, exceeding the $126.86 ride-hail round trip.

More Local Trips Can Favor Car Rental

The comparison changes again when the traveler needs transportation beyond the two airport transfers.

Ad Loading...

A traveler making several journeys during the day would incur a separate ride-hail fare for each trip. The rental rate, by contrast, gives the customer continuous access to a vehicle throughout the rental period.

Amex GBT concluded that rental becomes more cost-effective as the number of local journeys increases. Avoiding parking charges can further strengthen the case for renting.

The analysis also does not capture differences in convenience, wait times, vehicle availability, route flexibility or the ability to carry luggage and equipment. Those considerations may influence a traveler’s decision even when one option has a modest price advantage.

For rental operators, the findings show that car rental’s business travel value proposition is strongest when customers require multiple trips, flexibility or continuous vehicle access, not simply transportation from the airport and back.

The comparison was conducted during the fourth quarter of 2025 and was intended as an illustrative snapshot. Amex GBT cautioned that the figures should not be treated as currently bookable rates.

Ad Loading...

Our Take — Break it Down for the Customer

Auto Rental News has been having this debate since Uber and Lyft became viable transportation options in 2010. Back then and today, we still need to concentrate not on a daily rate versus a single fare, but the total cost of an itinerary.

Rental companies have an opportunity to make their value easier to recognize. How about an app in which a customer can enter the length of stay, expected mileage, and number of planned stops, and see an estimated break-even point between renting and buying rides individually. Adding realistic fuel, parking, and ancillary charges would make the comparison more credible, not less favorable.

Rental has traditionally been marketed as a product with a daily price when it should be presented as an itinerary-based mobility option. The company that helps travelers understand the full cost before they choose may have a greater advantage than the company displaying the lowest initial rate.


Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Articles

Man looking through window at car transporter
•November 17, 2026

Planning Rental Fleet Transfers When Receiving Locations Have Limited Space

Even a well-timed vehicle delivery can disrupt rental operations when space is limited. Here's how operators can plan fleet transfers around a branch's actual receiving capacity.

Read More →
Avis and Hertz logos against a money line graph
Rental Operations•by Chris Brown•November 15, 2026

Hertz, Avis: Parsing the Q3 Headwinds and Tailwinds

Third-quarter results from Hertz and Avis show resilient pricing despite softer travel demand. Meanwhile, higher operating costs, recalls, uneven vehicle depreciation, and international weakness continue to put pressure on profits.

Read More →
Thumbnail of NYC Idling Fines video with William Harris of Edge Auto Rental
Legal & Legislative•by Chris Brown•November 9, 2026

NYC Idling Tickets: How Rental Companies Can Face $2,000 Fines

A customer rents a diesel truck, idles it for three minutes while operating it, then returns it. Months later, the rental company gets a ticket that could cost up to $2,000. Edge Auto Rental's William Harris explains how New York City's idling enforcement creates headaches for rental operators.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
a rental car served on a silver platter
•by Chris Brown•November 9, 2026

What Can Daily Rental Operators Learn from Luxury Concierge Pickup and Delivery?

A seamless rental experience begins before the customer gets the keys. Luxury concierge practices offer lessons that work just as well for everyday rentals.

Read More →
Collage of cleaning car interior
Rental Operations•November 5, 2026

How Better Cleaning Processes Improve Rental Fleet Efficiency

A consistent approach to vehicle cleaning helps rental operators reduce turnaround delays and return vehicles to service without compromising cleanliness.

Read More →
rental fleet sales 2026 over 2025 through October
Fleet Acquisition•by Chris Brown•November 5, 2026

Rental Fleet Sales Turn Positive Through October 2026

October rental fleet sales rose 2.2% year over year, bringing year-to-date volume slightly ahead of 2025 for the first time since early in the year.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Paperwork sits in front of a black Lamborghini
Rental Operations•November 1, 2026

Clean on Paper: Red Flags in Exotic Car Rental Verification

A suspicious $45,000 Lamborghini booking reveals the strengths and limitations of renter verification, from forged insurance documents to coverage gaps and unauthorized drivers. (Part 2 of 3)

Read More →
display of Turo's FSD homepage
Rental Operations•by Chris Brown•October 28, 2026

Turo and Tesla Take the Next Step Toward Autonomous Car Rentals

The partnership brings Tesla's Full Self-Driving (Supervised) technology into the rental experience, offering a glimpse of how increasingly automated vehicles could change car rental.

Read More →
Two identical rental cars, two different prices
Rental Operations•Cover Story•October 26, 2026

How Rental Operators Can Navigate Personalized Pricing Rules

As regulators scrutinize the use of customer data in pricing, rental operators need to know whether they can explain why one renter pays more than another.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
a laptop shows different connectivity paths for car rental supply
Rental Operations•October 23, 2026

Direct, Broker or Hybrid? How Travel Retailers Source Rental Cars

As travel retailers weigh direct supplier relationships against third-party distribution, rental operators need to understand how those decisions affect their business.

Read More →
Ad Loading...